Exercise for Double Bass Utilizing Larry Grenadier's Concepts of Odd Meter

Authors

  • Suphawut Phimnon Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences, Loei Rajabhat University, Loei, Thailand

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.59796/rmj.V20N2.2025.R0507

Keywords:

Skills Practice, Double Bass, Odd Meter, Larry Grenadier

Abstract

The objective of this research is to create a double bass skill exercise based on an analysis of Larry Grenadier's conceptual arrangement of odd meter in his performances on Solar, Summertime, and It Might as Well Be Spring. The researcher has examined and formulated practice approaches based on this distinctive notion, categorizing them into four primary topics: 1) Analysis of rhythmic attributes in irregular meter, 2) Identification and selection of notes for harmonic structure, 3) Formulation of themes, and 4) Design of a practice framework for double bass performance emphasizing the handling of irregular meter.

This research encompasses: 1) Analyzing double bass performances to synthesis diverse notions that exemplify the distinctiveness in handling irregular meter, encompassing elements of melodic structure, harmony, scales, and additional factors. 2) The researcher emphasizes the examination of controlling irregular meter to formulate effective strategies. 3) In this research, the investigator utilizes Bert Ligon's concept of Motivic development as an analytical framework, in conjunction with Alistair Campbell Peel's techniques for altering rhythmic subdivisions in the clave format, the application of dotted rhythms within the specifics of rhythmic subdivisions, and theories from other scholars to elucidate.

The investigator sought information from pertinent research sources during the study. The research framework, methodology, and scope of the study were: 1) To delineate and categorize into the following principal points: The researcher formulated selection criteria emphasizing unique traits and conceptual frameworks within the compositions that may be utilized for skill development activities. 2) Data Verification: The double bass performance notes for the composition “Solar” were obtained from transcriptions by Michael Lucke, particularly for the works “Summertime” and “It Might as Well Be Spring.” The researcher personally transcribed the music, examining and comparing it with recorded performances that were first evaluated by specialists. 3) Data Analysis: The researcher examined the notes validated by experts in Western music theory and jazz theory to elucidate critical issues, including the organization of irregular meter, the establishment of clave in intricate time signatures, the motivic development, melodic progression, and the selection of notes pertinent to chordal harmony, encompassing tension notes and chord extensions. The investigation sought to discover unique traits present in various performances, resulting in the formulation of skill development activities. The researcher utilized the examined notes to develop preliminary skill exercises, elucidating the principles and substance of the exercises aimed at enhancing proficiency in odd meter rhythm. The exercises were developed to encompass notes from E2 to C5 on the double bass, commencing with basics in simple, compound, and complicated time, while incorporating the development of odd meter rhythms.

The analysis of performance themes in “Solar,” “Summertime,” and “It Might as Well be Spring” demonstrated that Larry Grenadier displayed intricate patterns in odd meter rhythms during both accompaniment and solo improvisation. The examination emphasized the utilization of tension notes and chord expansions. The results prompted the creation of skill exercises that were classified into three primary domains: 1) Rhythmic Attributes of Accompaniment Notes: Grenadier employed stratified rhythms using a pulse grouping metric displacement idea, leading to inconsistencies with the real-time signatures. For example, rhythmic grouping is used to create pulses of 5/2, 6/2, 6/4, and 9/8, which overlay the 4/4 meter. Additionally, there is a grouping of the clave in a 5/4 meter, where the main pulse is composed of 3+2, and the clave is divided into a pattern of 3 pulses. 2) Rhythmic Characteristics of Improvised Solo Notes: The notion of metric displacement was employed to generate melodies while regulating harmonic structure. This includes the use of triplet and dotted quarter notes, which can be seen as layering a 9/8 meter over a 4/4 meter. The study observed the execution of arpeggios, triads (major and minor), reduced scales, and harmonic minor scales. 3) Motivic Development in Irregular Meter: The research determined that employing motive presentation techniques such as repetition, diminution, augmentation, sequencing, adding notes, and omitting notes effectively sustained harmonic interest. The application of arpeggios and scales in motivic development Significantly heightened note tension and chord expansions in the improvised tunes.

The research conclusion and discussion: The examination of Larry Grenadier's double bass performance in “Solar,” “Summertime,” and “It Might as Well Be Spring” The researcher designed 10 skill exercises based on an analysis of Larry Grenadier's double bass performance. The results include the creation of a set of 10 skill exercises, emphasizing elements of accompaniment, solo improvisation, and Motivic development within irregular meter. Each exercise was thematically interconnected, progressing from easier to more complicated levels. The participants must have a basic understanding of rhythm and jazz music theory at or above Grade 8 of the woodwind curriculum from Trinity College London. This framework aims to clarify the elements of irregular meter and includes the structural development of ii7-V7-Imaj7 chord progressions and modulations to different keys, with rhythmic sequences and the movement of notes within motive clusters. Each practice encompasses a thorough array of 12 keys, covering the pitch range from E2 to C5, hence promoting the advancement of proficiency in double bass performance.

References

Bambarger, Bradley. “Larry Grenadier Biography.” Accessed March 27, 2020. http://larrygrenadier.com/larry-grenadier-the-gleaners-long-form.

Kunjara, Changton. “Diminished Scale Concepts for Jazz Improvisation.” Rangsit Music Journal 18, 1 (2023): 1-16. (in Thai)

Laohverapanich, Teerus. “Jazz Analysis.” Rangsit Music Journal 17, 2 (2022): 45-60. (in Thai)

Ligon, Bert. Comprehensive Technique for Jazz Musicians. 2nd ed. Houston, TX: Houston Publishing, 1999.

Lucke, Michael. “Brad Mehldau-Solar-Transcription.” Posted August 31, 2021, YouTube, 9.59. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_T3MlvECa5Q.

Luepradit, Anan. Jazz Musical Freedom of Humanity. Bangkok: Nation Group Publishing, 2002. (in Thai)

Pancharoen, Natchar. Music Dictionary. 5th ed. Bangkok: KateCarat, 2021. (in Thai)

Peel, Alistair C. “A Brief Exploration of Variances in Larry Grenadier’s Approach to Soloing in Piano Trio and Duo Contexts on Selected Recordings of all the Things You are and Long Ago and Far Away.” BMus thesis, Edith Cowan University, 2016.

Tirataradol, Noppadol. “An Analysis and Comparative Study in Walking Bass Line and Improvisation in Jazz Music of Charles Mingus Ray Brown and Eddie Gomez.” MA thesis, Mahidol University, 2001. (in Thai)

Trakulhun, Wiboon. Twentieth-Century Music. Bangkok: Chulalongkorn University Press, 2015. (in Thai)

Trapchak, Sam S. “Towards a Model of Jazz Bass Accompaniment on Standards Adapted to Uneven Meters: The Foundational Approaches of Larry Grenadier, Scott Colley and Johannes Weidenmueller.” MMus thesis, William Paterson University, 2009.

Downloads

Published

24.07.2025

How to Cite

Phimnon, Suphawut. 2025. “Exercise for Double Bass Utilizing Larry Grenadier’s Concepts of Odd Meter”. Rangsit Music Journal 20 (2):R0507 (20 pages). https://doi.org/10.59796/rmj.V20N2.2025.R0507.

Issue

Section

Research Article